Advertisement

From Ambition to Delivery: How councils can make fleet electrification work

Mike Nakrani, CEO of e-fleet solutions provider VEV, tells LAPV why councils struggle to move from commitment to delivery, and how better planning and procurement can help.

Many councils have declared climate emergencies and set net zero targets, but turning those commitments into electric fleets is proving harder. Nakrani says the barriers are funding, grid capacity and procurement processes that can favour large suppliers.

What is stopping councils moving to delivery?

Nakrani points first to funding, noting that surveys suggest around 90% of councils believe theirs is inadequate, and second to grid connections, given the power waste and bus depots need.

He argues power is a constraint rather than a barrier. ‘We built tens of depots last year,’ he says. ‘That tells me whilst power is a constraint, there is a way around it.’ In one case, a district council in Cambridgeshire could run only four electric refuse vehicles on its connection, so VEV built a microgrid using a small solar farm on council land. It won’t cover all demand, he says, but it reduces the grid upgrade needed. ‘Why doesn’t every large council shed have a battery and a microgrid solution? There’s no reason for it not to. It always pays back.’

Procurement is the third problem. Balance sheet requirements often rule out newer, smaller firms, pushing councils towards costlier providers. ‘It’s a self-defeating cycle,’ he says.

Building a credible business case

Councils must answer two questions, Nakrani says: is the technology feasible, and is it commercially viable? Route and duty-cycle data can show whether vehicles will do the job. On viability, ‘we can prove that the total cost of ownership lifetime is close to diesel or even better in many cases’, with today’s volatility in fuel costs adding another factor to that calculation. A VEV study for Hampshire found savings of 4 to 14% against diesel, and a trial of two electric refuse vehicles with Serco in the county saved nearly 9,000kg of CO2 in eight weeks.

His advice: ‘Start with the routes, make sure the maths works for them. Focus on the ones that can work.’ He says VEV’s data shows at least 30 to 40% of vehicles could go electric now at lower lifetime cost, and unusual cases, such as a single-day return trip from London to Edinburgh, shouldn’t hold up the rest.

Why plan everything together?

Most organisations start with the vehicle they want to buy, which usually causes problems. ‘If you buy the vehicles first and you inherit whatever grid and the site, it will end in a result that will be inefficient,’ Nakrani says. ‘The real reason projects don’t work is often because the plans aren’t thought through well enough upfront as a single solution.’

An integrated programme involves a lot of coordination: the network operator, civil engineers, connection providers, the energy supplier, fleet and maintenance teams, and landowners. He cites VEV’s work at First Bus’s Westbourne Park depot, where the depot stayed operational throughout construction despite a live rail line running underneath.

Few councils have spare capacity for this. ‘You’re giving them a top-down target, not giving them the resources, not giving them the right capability.’

How can councils start despite uncertainty?

‘Slice the elephant,’ Nakrani says: ‘phase the transition, use data and avoid piecemeal decisions. Design sites for future need. Dig the road up once, it’s lower cost.’

A plan doesn’t mean spending millions on consultants, he says, but a practical framework that can be tested with the committees that must approve it. He cites a study of over 100,000 buses, trucks, vans, which identified a reduction in the cost of grid upgrades of up to 70% and potential to deliver energy savings of up to 20% via charging strategy optimisation.

Concerns about battery life are also largely anecdotal, he argues.

Electrifying a local authority fleet must be done right because it will be an example to the whole area. As Nakrani says, ‘You need to make it as successful as possible, because that’s going to be the lighthouse.’

What needs to change across government and procurement?

‘Funding’s got to be simpler,’ Nakrani says. He cites Local Government Association research showing more than 60% of councils were put off bidding for net zero funds by the cost of preparing proposals, and 43% have returned funding because they couldn’t deliver within scheme restrictions. He’d like longer funding windows and fewer restrictions.

He also points to the Depot Charging Scheme, which he says makes around £170m available between 2026 and 2030 towards vehicles and charging infrastructure, and which councils can take part in, highlighting an opening of the window for a second wave of applications at the end October.

Above all, he wants councils to see electrification as a better option, not a cost burden. ‘The funding requirement is a short-term issue, at the beginning to get going, and the benefits come as the savings come over time,’ he says. ‘What we’re talking about is a transformation that is fundamentally better for people, better for the planet and better for business. Once you get over those early hurdles, it suddenly becomes a much more positive cycle.’

Photo: Mike Nakrani is CEO of e-fleet solutions provider VEV © VEV

 

 

 

 

Help us break the news – share your information, opinion or analysis
Back to top