Stockton-on-Tees Council’s plan to lease eight replacement gritters has cleared scrutiny after councillors unanimously decided not to overturn the Cabinet’s approval.
The proposed three-year deal is expected to cost about £300,000 a year, with the option of two further one-year extensions. The vehicles are intended to be ready for the 2027/28 winter season, when the existing fleet’s lease is due to end.
Six Conservative councillors had called in the Cabinet decision, seeking further examination of the procurement. At the Executive Scrutiny Committee meeting on 17 November, they questioned whether members had been given sufficient detail to favour leasing over buying vehicles, extending the existing arrangement or pursuing another procurement approach.
Conservative group leader Tony Riordan told the committee the decision papers did not explain why leasing was preferred. He said: ‘That’s an estimated annual cost of £330,000, potentially around £1.65m over five years. However, it does not explain why leasing was preferred over other options such as purchasing vehicles, extending arrangements or considering alternative procurement models.’
Deputy leader Paul Rowling defended the process, saying officers had assessed technical, operational and financial options before advising Cabinet. Rowling said Cabinet had received the information needed to decide and should rely on officers’ professional judgement.
Councillors also debated whether replacing all eight vehicles was proportionate to local needs. Labour member Jim Beall criticised the call-in as ‘nitpicking’, while Riordan said it was intended to ensure Cabinet had been properly informed. The committee ultimately found that the decision had been made appropriately and took no further action, allowing the procurement decision to proceed.
Photo: © M Barratt / Shutterstock.com.
Leave a Reply